Man vs. Crab: Renewable Limbs as Food

By Published On: 19 August 2013Last Updated: 17 January 2017

Man vs. Crab: can there be only one? Not if we're talking claws! But does a crab's regenerative abilities justify our harvesting of its claws?

What's in this post

stone crab

Through no fault of my own, I recently found myself watching an episode of Man Vs. Food. The premise: the show’s host travels across America, eating copious amounts of “food” (usually animals) in the form of 48 oz. steaks, giant heroes, and other meals that will eventually give him health issues, I imagine. I am disgusted by the gluttony and waste just as much as I am about the fact that a part of me finds this show entertaining (you know, as long as you ignore the fact that animals are dying for the “entertainment”).

In one segment of the episode I caught, they were at a crab place in Florida, praising the crab claws on the menu as “nature’s perfect gift”. Silly me, I thought they were just being the usual, delusional food biz guys, much like Chobani’s head, talking about how milk was a gift from nature. But no, they were talking about something else.

Turns out the Florida stone crab can grow a new claw in 12-18 months, so not only is crab claw a “sustainable” food product, but you can eat it guilt-free, since no crab is dying for it! I couldn’t help but wonder, though – wouldn’t the crab find it difficult to survive for a year or more with only one full claw? And, besides, how can one justify ripping a body part off of an animal and tossing it back into the ocean? Oh, wait – they do that to sharks all the time for a delicacy called “shark fin soup.”

The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission explains things:

  • Stone crabs lose claws in two ways: forcibly, when broken off by fishermen or lost in battle; or intentionally, if the crab drops its claw when damaged or sick.
  • A stone crab can re-grow either of its claws only if the joint that linked the claw to the body is left intact.
  • Post-claw break survival: In the wild, survival rates may approach 100 percent, but in a fishery, it depends on the fisherman breaking the claw correctly and how they handle the crabs before and after removal.

Is it just me, or does it all sound sort of risky? Shady? Unnecessary?

Stone crabs have the ability to lose and regenerate their claws as a survival tactic – not as a justification for human need to eat. Maybe it’s just me, but I don’t trust fisheries to break a crab’s claw gently any more than I trust a meat processor to gently handle the animals he kills for cuts of beef, chicken, or pork.

Photo credit: Andrea Westmoreland via Flickr

One Comment

  1. Nick June 26, 2021 at 7:08 pm - Reply

    Stone crabs losing a claw and being tossed back is nothing like cutting off the fins of a shark. The shark dies a gruesome death, just for 5 fins.
    There is almost no comparison

Leave A Comment

HELLO! I'm KD Angle-Traegner.

Writer, activist, and founder of Four Urban Paws Sanctuary. I’m on a mission to help people live a vegan life. Read more about KD…